Miss Cinderella 2010 - Chelsay Adams- Miss Mooreland
Miss Cinderella 2009 - Olivia Yandel - Miss South Barber
Miss Cinderella 2008 - Brittany Bisel - Miss Ringwood
Miss Cinderella 2007 - Paige Fischer - Miss Timberlake
Miss Cinderella 2006 - Ashlynn Frey - Miss Cimarron
Miss Cinderella 2005 - Talia Berning - Miss Alva
Miss Cinderella 2004 - Layne Armbruster - Miss Burlington
Miss Cinderella 2003 - Skyler Selby - Miss Gage
Miss Cinderella 2002 - Savannah White - Miss Alva
Miss Cinderella 2001 - Ashley Little - Miss Laverne
Miss Cinderella 2000 - Natalie Loeser - Miss Burlington
Miss Cinderella 1999 - Cassie McEachern - Miss Timberlake
Miss Cinderella 1998 - Jennifer Newton - Miss Woodward
Miss Cinderella 1997 - Kily Sander - Miss Woodward
Miss Cinderella 1996 - Sharie Surface - Miss Alva
Miss Cinderella 1995 - Kori Seaman - Miss Waynoka
Miss Cinderella 1994 - Leah Rohrer - Miss Woodward
Miss Cinderella 1993 - Tracey Clark - Miss Sharon-Mutual
Miss Cinderella 1992 - Robyn Girton - Miss Shattuck
Miss Cinderella 1991 - Amber Shaklee - Miss Aline-Cleo
Miss Cinderella 1990 - Kimberly Kennedy - Miss Drummond
Miss Cinderella 1989 - Danielle Calhoon - Miss Beaver
Miss Cinderella 1988 - Shana Woodson - Miss Alva
Miss Cinderella 1987 - Anita Tucker - Miss Jet-Nash
Miss Cinderella 1986 - Jill Newton - Miss Aline-Cleo
Miss Cinderella 1985 - Dorinda Stitt - Miss Dover
Miss Cinderella 1984 - Tammy Shaklee - Miss Jet-Nash
Miss Cinderella 1983 - Hope Ingle - Miss Dover
Miss Cinderella 1982 - Beth Hodges - Miss Woodward
Miss Cinderella 1981 - Michaelle McDaniel - Miss Cherokee
Miss Cinderella 1980 - Diane Kirsch - Miss Dover
Miss Cinderella 1979 - Terri Clark - Miss Woodward
Miss Cinderella 1978 - Aly Zalondek - Miss Kremlin
Miss Cinderella 1977 - Debbie Slater - Miss Carmen-Dacoma
Miss Cinderella 1976 - Fonda Smith - Miss Mooreland
Miss Cinderella 1975 - Leslie Ann Pearson - Miss Buffalo
Miss Cinderella 1974 - Terri Wilkerson - Miss Buffalo
Miss Cinderella 1973 - Penny Propp - Miss Canton
Miss Cinderella 1972 - Lucia Miller - Miss Buffalo
Miss Cinderella 1971 - Micki Lewis - Miss Lamont
Miss Cinderella 1970 - Mary Ann Tucker - Miss Jet-Nash
Miss Cinderella 1969 - Karen Jenkinson - Miss Burlington
Miss Cinderella 1968 - Dee Ann Purviance - Miss Mooreland
Miss Cinderella 1967 - Annie Arganbright - Miss Alva
Miss Cinderella 1966 - Jill Wright - Miss Cherokee
Miss Cinderella 1965 - Linda Beam - Miss Arnett
Miss Cinderella 1964 - Marilyn Martin - Miss Hudson
Miss Cinderella 1963 - Jane Jayroe - Miss Laverne
Miss Cinderella 1962 - Vicki Fry - Miss Forgan
Miss Cinderella 1961 - Nancy Ann Ellis - Miss Jet
Miss Cinderella 1960 - Patsy Bullard - Miss Arnett
Miss Cinderella 1959 - Sherry Vincent - Miss Freedom
Miss Cinderella 1958 - Phoebe Jane Woodward - Miss Fairview
Miss Cinderella 1957 - Rosetta Buss - Miss Laverne
Miss Cinderella 1956 - Donita Jean French - Miss Freedom
Miss Cinderella 1955 - Donna Jean Rogers - Miss Shattuck
Miss Cinderella 1954 - Marilyn Middleton - Miss Waynoka
Miss Cinderella 1953 - Jerry Jean Gragg - Miss Cherokee
Miss Cinderella 1952 - Bonnie Rauh - Miss Alva